The Tale of Cutter's Treasure is an Are You Afraid of the Dark? television episode. It was written by Chloe Brown and directed by D. J. MacHale. It first aired October 29, 1994. This is the first of a two-part episode. The second part The Tale of Cutters Treasure Part II concluded the story.
When a teenager finds a spyglass locked in a treasure chest at Sardo's Magic Mansion, the ghost of an evil pirate is released.